Fans of the Tyneside club are more and more seeing Eddie Howe's side as a fickle companion. On their day, they prove to be the ultimate thrill-seekers, unleashing high-octane exhibitions. However, in other matches, key figures like Sandro Tonali and his teammates simply do not show up.
Exacerbating the frustration is a second-half approach laced with a pronounced streak of panic. Before their Boxing Day to Manchester United, the numbers paint a concerning story: the team has let slip thirteen crucial top-flight points from leading positions this term and are without a clean sheet in 10 consecutive outings across all competitions. Securing a win at Old Trafford would represent only their second-ever league triumph on the travel this year.
Conversely, a loss has only come once in their most recent 6 Premier League encounters, and although sitting in a modest eleventh spot, they are a only six points off the highly-prized Champions League places. Add in an looming two-legged League Cup semi-final against the reigning champions and a decent opportunity of advancing to the European Cup knockout phase, and it becomes simpler to appreciate the manager's cautious hope.
“We don't just have problems,” said the team's manager. “You can see positives as well. I am firmly positive at present. I understand everybody else may hold a divergent view, but in my view we are making progress.”
The puzzle persists: will this collection of players match – or even surpass – the achievements of the previous campaign's cup glory and European-qualifying finish? Juggling a congested schedule makes this difficult.
This fatigue may be the reason behind the inability to sustain a stellar first-half showing against Chelsea, eventually letting slip a two-goal advantage to draw 2-2. Similarly, it is possibly the culprit for a poor display in a painful defeat to arch-rivals Sunderland, where the side appeared lethargic just days after a demanding European away day.
While on-field instruction is undoubtedly Howe's specialty, the relentless grind of two games a week football has severely reduced essential practice sessions. This hinders the team's stylistic adaptation to playing with summer signing Nick Woltemade up front, rather than the departed Alexander Isak. Although extremely talented, Woltemade has not shown the equivalent blistering breakaway speed or intense defensive work rate.
Indeed, the side's signature high press has occasionally failed. Injuries to crucial component the Brazilian midfielder have not helped, while expensive arrivals Anthony Elanga and the English midfielder have had difficulties adapting since their big-money moves.
While a switch to a three-man defense could arguably help the team, a severe backline absence list renders that difficult. Key full-backs will be absent for the next crucial fixtures, challenging the team's resilience.
At their energetic best, they seem virtually unplayable. The catch is sustaining that fervor for the full 90 minutes. The go-to plan B of dropping deep into a deep-lying counter-attacking formation has at times been self-destructive.
“The Chelsea game became anarchic at two-all,” said the manager. “But the intention was trying to win. Our mentality is to always go out to secure the three points.”
What seems required is a middle ground – one featuring better possession control, a engine room adept of slowing the pace, and a realistic willingness to sometimes accept a point. Yet, a desire to compete on all fronts is stretching thin player resources to their breaking point.
It may seem sacrilegious to some, but a different approach in the cup competitions in the initial stages could have alleviated the present fixture congestion. With critical European and league games on the agenda, the necessity to carefully prioritize is becoming ever more apparent.
Eddie Howe recognized the scale of the task remaining. “Being at this club, the pressures are big. Every moment's crucial. There is progress to be made in the league. We're in the League Cup semi-finals, we aim to progress in the Champions League and do well in the FA Cup.
“We're moving in the right direction, but we have lots of improvement to do to transform into the regularly successful team we envision. Our capacity to string together sequences of victories has deserted us so far.
“The task is to hit those levels we are aware we're capable of. My feeling is that the self-belief we can do that is coming back. But now we have to show it. It ain't all bad in this moment, but the coming period will shape a great deal.”
A passionate storyteller and cultural observer, Elara shares insights from her global travels and everyday experiences to inspire authentic living.